Which Bluegills are Better to Keep?

June 27, 2022

John Martino

John Martino

Every spring and summer questions are raised by serious bluegill fishermen. How many bluegills should a single person keep? Is it better to keep the males or females? The answer depends on who you ask.

How Many Bluegills People Should Keep

Most anglers and fishery biologists are in agreement that there’s nothing wrong or unethical about plucking a stringer full of gills off spawning beds during springtime. They are easy to spot, can congregate in large numbers and easy to catch.

Bluegills are the most prolific native gamefish in Indiana. They build hundreds of saucer shaped nests and some might even bed multiple times a year, producing thousands of eggs with each spawn.

But the debate continues. There is one camp of anglers who believe in taking only the males, since there are generally more of them. They are conservative in taking females since they are the egg-layers.

A Different Theory on Bluegills

At age 64, Bob Ramer, who lives in Kosciusko County, lives to fish for the tasty panfish. But he has a different theory.

“The males are the ones who protect the nest after the females drop their eggs,” he noted. “When you take the male, it exposes the eggs for other fish to raid. I think it’s better to take the females.”

In case you’re wondering, you can tell the difference in gender by coloration. Males are far more colorful and have a bright orange patch under the chin. Females generally are less showy.

Ramer, as well as many serious bluegill fanatics, is also concerned that a red-hot spawning season, like the one this spring, can hurt bluegill quality in small lakes. People can congregate and take large numbers of the tasty fish, and although not depleting the lake, they can seriously diminish the numbers of those that are keeper size.

One Major Reason

This is one reason ethical pan fishermen encourage others to use common sense with the number of sunfish they take home. For that reason some prefer to fish multiple lakes during the spawn to avoid reaping too many from one single body of water.

Jeremy Price, IDNR Fisheries Supervisor, says there’s no biological reason to be overly concerned with taking males over females or vice-versa.

“First, the female spends very little time on the nest,” he explained. “Secondly, although the males may spend more time there, they don’t guard the nest as diligently or aggressively as a bass does during the spawning season,” he added. “More importantly, bluegills are laying thousands of eggs and are biologically engineered to produce far more young than a lake can handle.” In other words, it’s extremely hard to completely fish out a lake with bluegills.

Several Factors Come Into Play

Price says there are several factors that come into play when deciding on how many to keep. “It can go either way,” he explained. “If the lake has a large number of bigger fish then you want to be judicious with your catch so you help protect the size quality of the population.” On the other hand Price says if the lake has a large number of smaller, stunted fish then large numbers need to be removed. “In this area it takes a bluegill seven years to reach eight inches,” he added.

Although Indiana does not have a size or bag limit on the popular pan fish, some states do. But that could change in the future since many believe there should be restrictions on the number a person should keep for the frying pan.

“A bag limit may not affect the overall population, but it could help distribute the size,” Price explained. “Plus we just finished our annual survey of licensed anglers and two-thirds of respondents think there should be some type of creel limit.”

Article courtesy of The SportsmanClick Here to subscribe to The Sportsman for more journalism, opinion and stories from the sporting life.

Read more about bluegills on iSportsmanUSA.
Photo courtesy of Unsplash.


More About Tactics


Redfish Fishing: A Quick & Easy Beginners Guide

May 17, 2024 iSportsman Staff


Giant Snapping Turtles: Everything You Need to Know

May 14, 2024 Connor Merritt


Nightcrawlers and Earthworms: Your Guide for Fishing Success

May 10, 2024 iSportsman Staff


Bone Broth 101: A Wild Game Best-Kept Secret

April 29, 2024 iSportsman Staff

View All