The History of Elk Hunting in Pennsylvania

November 30, 2023

E. Lawrence

E. Lawrence

The history of elk hunting in Pennsylvania is a story of renewed opportunities. Hunters nearly brought Elk to extinction in Pennsylvania. The forests where native elk once lived are now providing habitat for descendants of Rocky Mountain elk. Over a century has passed since the first Yellowstone elk were transplanted into the north central region of the state and conservation efforts have caused significant annual herd growth in the last few decades. This elk population increase has led the Pennsylvania Game Commission to conduct annual elk hunts in Pennsylvania. In 2001, 30 licensed elk hunters harvested 27 elk. These were the first elk hunters took during a Pennsylvania elk hunting season in over 70 years.

The History of Elk Hunting in Pennsylvania

Two elk in field elk hunting elk hunting in Pennsylvania

The colonization and development of lands, along with exploitation by European settlers, brought an end to the eastern elk of Pennsylvania. By the late 1870’s the last of the eastern elk subspecies were extinct. One of these last known elk native to the state of Pennsylvania is likely to have been taken from Flag Swamp, near St. Mary’s, in Elk County. Jim Jacobs took this elk after a pursuit lasting several days. Strongholds in the hills of Pennsylvania’s north central counties were the last places these animals were once found.

Today, we can still find elk thriving in the hills of north central Pennsylvania. In fact, one of the largest herds of elk found east of the Rocky Mountains lives here. Elk numbers in Pennsylvania are currently between 800-900 animals. These elk however are not descendants of eastern elk. Government officials actually introduced elk currently residing in Pennsylvania from western stocks of Rocky Mountain Elk.

The Creation of the Game Commission

Pennsylvania’s declining numbers of wildlife brought the creation of the Game Commission in 1895. In 1912, the Game Commissioners and Executive Secretary Joseph Kalbfus began talking about the reintroduction of elk in Pennsylvania. Elk herds at Yellowstone National Park and the Jackson Hole Refuge Area grew to unsustainable levels and these preserves protected what was left of America’s elk population. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Bureau of Biological Survey and Department of Forestry decided instead of sanctioning a hunt to decrease elk numbers on western preserves, that they would be willing to relocate the animals to Pennsylvania.

The Game Commission needed to pay the expenses of capture and transportation to reintroduce elk into Penn’s Woods. It would cost $30 per elk. This was a small price to pay in order to bring these majestic creatures back to the state. They decided that in order for the effort to be successful, they needed to set the reintroduced elk free in the largest tracts of state forests as far away from cultivated land as possible.

Yellowstone Helps Out

And so in 1913 the first shipment of Yellowstone elk arrived by train. Officials released half of these elk in Clinton County. They released the other half in Monroe County. Officials purchased another 22 elk from a private Monroe County preserve. These animals were released on state lands in Monroe County and a preserve in Centre County.

In 1915,  officials brought in 95 more Yellowstone elk into six north central Pennsylvania counties. The elk herd was beginning to grow. At this time farmers began to complain about crop losses, blaming the reintroduced elk. Poachers also started to take some of the transplanted elk. Still, elk numbers in the state continued to grow.

The First Official Elk Hunt

The first scheduled event for elk hunting in Pennsylvania did not take place until 1923. Bulls with at least four points to one antler were legal game for the two week elk season slated for the 1923 hunting season. Still hunting and stalking were the only hunting methods allowed. The government banned organized drives and hunters who did not comply were subject to a $100 fine.

During the first season of elk hunting in Pennsylvania, hunters harvested 23 legal bulls. The next three years saw a total harvest of 25 elk bulls. The 1927 season marked the highest total of elk bulls taken in Pennsylvania with 26 bulls harvested. Then the hunt totals dramatically declined until only one bull was harvested in 1930. Experts estimated elk numbers around 200 animals at this time. The herd began retreating to the same areas where the last of the eastern elk had once found refuge in Elk and Cameron counties.

The Impact of World War II on Elk Hunting in Pennsylvania

Interest in elk hunting in Pennsylvania faded into general obscurity from the beginning of World War II until the 1970’s. It is during this time that conservative counts numbered the heard at about 100 animals. Visitors to the region would marvel at the elk roaming the hills of north central Pennsylvania. Farmers on the other hand were losing patience with the elk encroaching on bordering crop fields. The Pennsylvania Game Commission wouldn’t until later begin to ponder the future of elk in the state.

A meeting at Emporium to discuss the state of Pennsylvania’s elk herd in 1970 began a time of renewed interest. It is during this time that several agencies including the Department of Environmental Resources and Penn State researchers began studying the elk herd and ways to improve habitat for the animals.

Tracking the Elk Population

Elk in field elk hunting elk hunting in Pennsylvania

The first time people fit an elk in Pennsylvania with a marking collar to track their movement was 1981. Research and studies of elk during the 1980’s focused on elk movements and their home range. These studies helped with insight of elk food preferences, seasonal movements, and habitat uses. In the early 1990’s, elk research and monitoring concentrated on herd reproduction, calf mortality, and health profile data.

The elk herd in Pennsylvania continued to grow during the 1990’s. By the year 2000 the elk herd numbered over 500 animals. Research, habitat management, and deterrent fencing were a few of the reasons why elk flourished. The public also began to take more notice of the elk in Pennsylvania.

Nearly 20,000 hunters now apply for tags to go elk hunting in Pennsylvania each year. The elk license drawings are based on a preference system. This means that hunters who do not draw elk tags will be given a preference point for each year they do not draw an elk tag. Non-residents of Pennsylvania can also draw tags.

Modern Day Elk Hunting in Pennsylvania

Elk hunters who are fortunate enough to draw a tag can find several experienced guides to help go elk hunting in Pennsylvania. A guide can greatly enhance your hunting experience and increase your chances of harvesting an elk in Pennsylvania. Guides know the area where the elk live and spend a lot of time scouting the areas. Individuals who draw an elk tag will get a list of permitted guides before the hunt. The Game Commission and the Department of Conservation & Natural Resources regulates elk guides. Employing the services of an elk guide/outfitter is completely up to the hunter but not required.

By doing some research, elk hunters can find the right guide for their hunt and also do well to learn more about elk in Pennsylvania. An adult bull elk can way up to 1,000 pounds. Cows top out around 600 pounds. Planning and preparation is very important: Hunters must prepare themselves thoroughly transport a harvested elk.

A trophy bull elk in Pennsylvania is a truly magnificent animal. When I asked a respected taxidermist if he has ever mounted a Pennsylvania elk, he replied, “Pennsylvania bulls are much larger than the ones out West.” He added, “I used to do their head mounts, but the antlers are so heavy it became too difficult.” He still does the mounts for his clients who bring elk back from out West.

Article and photo courtesy of Harvesting Nature. Click here to subscribe to the quarterly Harvesting Nature magazine, And Click here to enjoy the latest episode of the wild fish and game podcast.

Connect with E. Lawrence
Website: NWPAOutdoors.com
Email: EdwardLawrencePA1@hotmail.com
Facebook: NWPAOutdoors.com

Read about a retired veteran who returned to elk hunting on iSportsmanUSA.


More About Tactics


Alligator Gar: The Apex Predator of Freshwater Fishing

June 13, 2024 iSportsman Staff


A Freshwater Sunfish Fishing Guide for Beginners

June 5, 2024 iSportsman Staff


Understanding Chigger Bites: Prevention and Treatment

June 3, 2024 Connor Merritt


Understanding Ballistic Coefficients for Hunters

May 30, 2024 iSportsman Staff

View All