Connor Merritt

Some of the most sought-after game fish found in freshwater environments are the muskie and the pike. The matchup: muskie vs pike — in one corner we have the muskie: a long, lean fighting machine. In the other corner we have the pike: a short, stocky little fish jockey. What’s the difference between these two challengers and which one will come out on top as the better game fish? Read on to find out!

Why They Get Mixed Up

One of the reasons why anglers can get these two fish confused is thanks to the fact that they are both part of the Esox genus, which means they are both part of the pike family, but the term pike also refers to a specific species of fish as well, known as Northern pike.

Muskie vs Pike: Physical Appearance

• Muskie (muskellunge): Muskies tend to have longer, leaner bodies, with a pointed snout and flat head. Their coloration is usually light, with dark vertical bars or spots on their sides; additionally, their fins are more rounded.
• Pike (northern pike): Pike have a stockier build with a shorter, more rounded snout. Their bodies are generally darker with lighter, oval-shaped spots, giving them a more camouflaged appearance. Plus, their tails and fins have a sharper, forked shape compared to muskies.

Size

• Muskie: Known as “the fish of 10,000 casts,” muskies are often larger than pike, with some reaching over 50 inches and weighing upwards of 40 pounds. They average between 28–48 inches and 15–35 pounds.
• Pike: Though still formidable in size, pike tend to be smaller on average, usually averaging between 16–22 inches and weighing between 2–5 pounds.

SUBSCRIBE TO THE iSPORTSMANUSA NEWSLETTER FOR MORE STORIES LIKE THIS

Muskie vs Pike: Habitat

• Muskie: Muskies are more selective with their habitat; you can often find them in clear, vegetated lakes and rivers. They tend to favor cooler waters and can be found in a smaller range of both northern U.S. and Canadian waters.
• Pike: Pike are more adaptable and can thrive in a broader range of environments, including murky and shallower waters. They are often found in lakes, rivers, and reservoirs throughout North America, and even Europe.

Muskie vs Pike: Behavior

• Muskie: Muskies are more solitary hunters. They tend to follow a “hunt-and-stalk” approach, sitting and waiting with incredible patience before striking their prey with sudden bursts of speed — this is one factor as to why muskies can be harder to catch.
• Pike: Pike are opportunistic feeders and tend to be more aggressive than muskies. They are known to attack a wider variety of prey and are often more willing to strike at lures. This is one of the biggest reasons that make them more consistent prey for anglers.

Muskie vs Pike: Fishing Techniques

• Muskie: Due to their elusive nature, muskie fishing requires plenty of patience. Larger, slow-moving lures such as bucktails, spinnerbaits, and jerkbaits tend to be effective. Cast your line over their preferred habitat and start trolling to cover a lot of water.
• Pike: Pike are less selective and often strike lures like spoons, spinners, jigs and hard plastic baits. Cast over their preferred habitat from a stationary position or start trolling to cover more ground. Anglers can expect more frequent bites but should be prepared for powerful resistance.

Conclusion: Muskie is More Rewarding, While Pike is More Reliable

Muskies take the crown for being the more-prized catch thanks to their increased difficulty and elusive nature; however, that doesn’t make pike any less worthwhile to go after. They’re more reliable and tend to provide fishermen more frequent action, giving you more bang for your buck on average.

Regardless of which one you decide to go after, there’s no wrong way to get out on the water and have a good time casting some lines. Just make sure you follow the tips in this article and understand the difference between the two, then you’ll be on your way to your very own victory. The true winner in the muskie vs pike matchup is the fisherman who catches them.

Read more fishing stories on iSportsmanUSA.