Fixed-Blade Broadhead Tips: How to Choose One Right for You

September 22, 2023

iSportsman Staff

iSportsman Staff

It can lead to a frustrating day of tracking a blood trail and hoping for a downed animal — choosing the right broadhead for your bowhunt is essential. After all, no one wants to leave an unclaimed target injured in the wild; it’s always better to tag your target on the first try. That’s why we listened to those who shared their first-hand experience on choosing the best fixed blade broadhead. 

Firstly, It’s Not About the Blade 

While there are some fan favorites out there that have corroborating good reviews from expert publications, any guy worth their salt will tell you up front that when it comes down to it, it’s not about the blade. A successful and impactful bowhunt and a good experience with whatever is at the end of your arrow is all about the fine tuning of your bow — and finding the bow that is best suited for your needs. iSportsmanUSA recently covered how to choose the best recurve bow, and how to choose the best compound bow. However, if you’re interested in what’s popular with those who know best, you should read on for more information. 

Fan Favorite #1: The QAD Exodus Standard Broadhead 

QAD manufactures their products in Madison Heights, Virginia, and takes pride in providing locals with rewarding careers. As a result of their strong core values, QAD remains dedicated to providing quality archery products for multiple uses. That may be why the QAD Exodus broadhead is quickly mentioned as a fan favorite. Therefore, the Exodus is a standout choice for those who subscribe to the theory that the smaller the broadhead, the better the shot. A three-pack will run you $49.99 at Cabela’s.

QAD Exodus Standard features: 

  • Super short head with a hardened SST tip 
  • Razor sharp 0.40” thick stainless-steel blades 
  • 1.25” Cutting diameter.  

Fan Favorite #2: The Magnus Stinger Fixed-Blade Broadhead 

The leader of Cut on Contact broadheads, Magnus produces a large line of broadheads that have main blades which can be resharpened and reused while maintaining pinpoint accuracy. A one-pack of the Magnus fixed-blade broadhead will run you $37.99 to $39.99 at Cabela’s, but with that you gain the benefit of aircraft aluminum ferrule and an ultra-strong diamond tip. 

Magnus Stinger Features: 

  • Stainless steel blades 
  • 1-1/16” cutting diameter. 
  • Spin tested for accuracy. 

Fan favorite #3: The Muzzy MX-3 3-Blade 


Muzzy primarily makes bowfishing products, and currently hosts the nation’s largest bowfishing tournaments. However, these water-resistant blades can be used on land as well. The Muzzy MX-3 goes for around $39.99 for a three pack and replacement blades are available for longtime and lifetime use.  

Muzzy MX-3 features: 

  • Available in 100 grain 
  • Trocar tip 
  • Anodized aluminum ferrule 
  • 0.025” Thickness blades 
  • 1 1/4” Cutting Diameter 

Fan favorite #4: Tooth and Arrow Fixed Blade Broadheads 

Finally, Tooth and Arrow offers two sizes of fixed blade broadheads designed for different hunting situations: a one-inch blade for long-shot scenarios, and a 1-3/16-inch one for smaller and medium sized game. Additionally, all their broadheads come in a range of weights to match your set-up, with the one-inch model available from 85-grain to 150-grain and the 1-2/16-inch model available in 100-grain to 175-grain. Tooth and Arrow prides itself on their high-quality, USA sources and manufactured products.  

Check out this new bow rack from Grey Man Tactical on iSportsmanUSA. 


TFO horizontal ad

More About Gear


iSportsman Cyber Monday Apparel 25% Off Storewide

November 27, 2023 iSportsman Staff


iSportsman Hunting Apparel Black Friday 24-HR Sale

November 24, 2023 iSportsman Staff


iSportsman Holiday Gift Guide 2023

November 21, 2023 iSportsman Staff


Shop Black Friday with Sitka Gear Sale

November 20, 2023 iSportsman Staff

View All